There are thousands of nail colors to choose from, and so many more constantly being introduced to the market. There’s literally a color to suit every personality, outfit and season, but certain colors always stand out among the crowd and become instant favorites. When it comes to fall nail colors, there are a select few that have become our go-tos time and time again, year after year, and we’re sharing our favorites with you today. We consider these the best fall nail polishes of all time, and we’re sure that after checking out the nail colors on our list (and trying some of them!), you’ll agree that we totally nailed it!

Smith & Cult Nailed Lacquer, Lover’s Creep ($18)

OPI Nail Lacquer, Big Apple Red ($10.49)

OPI Nail Lacquer, Bogotá Blackberry ($10)

Essie Nail Polish, After School Boy Blazer ($8.99)

OPI Nail Lacquer, Black Cherry Chutney ($10)

NARS Shimmer Nail Polish, Tokaido Express ($8.75)

Essie Nail Polish, Merino Cool ($8.99)

OPI Nail Lacquer, Malaga Wine Nail Lacquer ($10.49)

Sally Hansen Complete Salon Manicure, Pat on the Black ($6.59)

Essie Nail Polish, Wicked Nail Enamel ($8.99)

OPI Nail Lacquer, Washington D.C. Nail Lacquer Collection: We The Female ($10.50)

Smith & Cult Nailed Lacquer, Ghost Edit ($18)