While it has been quiiiiiiiite a while since we’ve been in our teens, some of our beauty habits haven’t changed. Of course, our preferences have changed for the most part, especially with all the new information about animal testing and clean ingredients. But we’ve hung on to a few key beauty products that still hold up, even all these years later. Here are the items that still have a home in our beauty cabinet.
Thayers Alcohol-Free Witch Hazel Rose Petal Toner
I’ve tried a lot of toners over the years, but I somehow always end up back at this one. I love how it is gentle but effective at cleansing my skin after I use my face wash. – Sam
Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips
I can only ever find these at small beauty supply stores these days, but it’s worth the search! I have been using this as part of my bronzing and highlighting routine, on and off, since I was in high school. It’s a very forgiving powder, plus you can amplify it with a spritz of your favorite setting spray on your brush first. – Wendy
Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer
There’s a reason why this tinted moisturizer has a cult following. It gives just the right amount of coverage while still keeping skin hydrated. – Sam
Wet n’ Wild Retractable Eyeliner
When I was a teen, budget-friendly was the name of the game. I don’t wear as much bottom liner as I did in my younger days, but when I do, this is still a favorite go-to. – Sam
Maybelline Color Sensational Lipstick
I’ve been a huge fan of Maybelline lipsticks since I could wear makeup, and they have never let me down…even when I didn’t know the purpose of lip liner. – Wendy
I can’t even remember how old I was when I started using the infamous Rosebud Salve. I’ve tried different variations over the year, but I always have a tin on my nightstand. – Sam
This is another lip product I’ve used for years. My favorite color is Red Dahlia—it gives the perfect natural pop of color. I always have a tube in my purse. – Sam
Shop tried-and-true beauty products:
